Russian animation for the holidays (part 3)
This is Part 3 of an overview of the Russian/Soviet holiday-themed animated films that are currently available to be watched with English subtitles (or wordless) on Animatsiya.net, listed from earliest to latest. Each film will have a description, as well as a summary of what’s good about it (why you may enjoy watching it), and what’s bad about it (why you may not want to watch it).
Part 1 was written back in December 2021, reviewing 31 films. Part 2 was written in December 2023, adding 17 new films. This part covers 12 films newly added to the site since then. All of them are in the picture below:

As before, each film below is rated; here’s what the ratings mean:
**** - I loved it
*** - I liked it
** - I thought it was ok
* - I didn’t like it
(no stars) - haven’t watched it yet (or not recently)
The ratings are based on my own feelings, and other people may feel differently. Also, a lot of the ** ones do have things that I like about them.
Firefly 8 (1968) **

The final entry in the Firefly series - a "film-journal" of short cartoons for kids. It would be replaced by the similar but more artistically daring Merry-Go-Round the following year. The 3rd and final story takes place around a holiday tree, though it’s not especially seasonal otherwise.
The good: Animated versions of some popular characters from Soviet children’s magazines of the time. Each story has a little moral. The second one ("Gimmebuythatgiftmea") is amusing for parents.
The bad: Engaging for kids, but less so for adults. Quite average.
A Fir Tree Was Born in the Wood (1972) **

The good: It is based on a very well-known winter holiday song, which is well-sung. It more-or-less has the right holiday atmosphere.
The bad: The art direction is not very inspired (a bit like American low-budget TV animation of the period). The song is interrupted before it finishes and the final lines are changed to insert a message about how the tree shouldn’t really be cut down.
Well, Just You Wait (8) (1974) ****

Wolf chases Bunny through a crowd of people celebrating the coming New Year. Along the way, they sing a duet with Bunny as Father Frost (the Russian Santa Claus) and Wolf as his daughter, the Snow Maiden.
The good: A classic, beloved winter holiday cartoon. Lots of action and humour. Plenty of fun scenes, and holiday atmosphere.
The bad: Like always with this series, if you’re looking for depth, you won’t find it. But it’s far less repetitive (due to the many changes of location in each episode) than the Western "Tom & Jerry" that it’s often compared to.
The Fir (1981) ***

The life story of a fir tree, set to classical piano music.
The good: Atmospheric and relaxed, with good music and painted animation.
The bad: Very short (like the other films by Samsonov in this "series"), the ending is quite sudden. A deeper but sadder version of this story is told in The Little Fir (1983).
Wonderful New Year’s Night (1984) ***

Rejected toys from a factory come alive and begin to look for a home.
The good: A surprisingly sweet Estonian winter holiday puppet animation, made more in the style of the 1960s than the 1980s.
The bad: Possibly a bit slow for some? I can’t find anything else bad to say, really, though I don’t think it’s the best film ever, either.
The Blue Arrow (1985) ****

The good: An absolutely charming puppet animation with great holiday spirit, warm feelings and an engaging (and slightly strange) plot.
The bad: This is probably a great simplification of Gianni Rodari’s original novel, so I don’t know what those who are familiar with it will think.
A Lacy Fairy-Tale (1992) ***

The good: Nice folk songs, relaxed, old-timey atmosphere. Slightly odd story in which Father Frost seems to be a young lad who falls in love with a kindred "artist".
The bad: The art, though often nice, is also amateurish in places. The film develops slowly and the plot is rather thin.
Yuletide Stories (1994) ***

Two beautiful, religious Christmas-themed stories. About the night of Christ’s birth, and a good deed that is remembered many decades later
The good: Excellent art direction, music and direction. A very peaceful and introspective atmosphere, like some other Belarusian films around the same time.
The bad: The English translation isn’t as effective as the Russian original, especially for the firt story. Also, I think the atmosphere is stronger than the plots themselves.
The Little Angel (2008) ***

A story about how a Christmas tree toy - a little wax angel - changed everything in the heart of a boy deprived of his mother’s love. Based on a story by Leonid Andreyev, and a poem by Vladimir Nabokov.
The good: Well-drawn, animated with paint-on-glass. Hopeful and wholesome.
The bad: The film does its best to be optimistic, downplay the bad parts of the boy’s character, and assume that the "religious awakening" leads to a happy ending, while the original story is more ambivalent about how much of a difference it can or will ultimately make to the fates of the characters beyond that one Christmas night. Because of that, the story comes across as more honest.
Catboy and the New Year (2016) **

The good: Neat idea: a film based on the drawings & story of a child who misinterprets some of the things adults talk about in amusing ways. A bit like a modern version of the Brumberg sisters' famous Big Troubles (1960), but not as sharp.
The bad: It feels a little artificial. Not all references are understandable unless you live there. It feels like a warmup for the later Pushkin cartoon based on children’s drawings from the same studio: My Pushkin (2023)
Fir Trees (2017) ***

The good: Nice animation (as is often the case from Sharafutdinov). An emotional roller-coaster ride.
The bad: An emotional roller-coaster ride; bizarre sudden tone change from wacky to absolutely depressing.
Umka at the Holiday Tree (2019) **

The good: the "unfinished" story from the 1st two films is finally finished, adapted from the concluding story written by the original author. The art style tries to stay close to the original. There is a bit of the lyricism from the first two films.
The bad: Something about it feels off. It feels quite "modern" and even somewhat hyper. Maybe the stories didn’t need to be finished? It really seemed to me like the open-ended endings of the first two film was a big part of their DNA. Each of them ends with two characters who love each other separated and not knowing if they’ll ever see each other again. On the one hand, I can see the appeal in "finishing" things, but on the other hand…
P.S. My apologies for posting this list so late in the month. I was delayed while I fixed a new bug that had begun to prevent most VK video thumbnails on the site from loading.
Part 1 was written back in December 2021, reviewing 31 films. Part 2 was written in December 2023, adding 17 new films. This part covers 12 films newly added to the site since then. All of them are in the picture below:

As before, each film below is rated; here’s what the ratings mean:
**** - I loved it
*** - I liked it
** - I thought it was ok
* - I didn’t like it
(no stars) - haven’t watched it yet (or not recently)
The ratings are based on my own feelings, and other people may feel differently. Also, a lot of the ** ones do have things that I like about them.
Firefly 8 (1968) **

The final entry in the Firefly series - a "film-journal" of short cartoons for kids. It would be replaced by the similar but more artistically daring Merry-Go-Round the following year. The 3rd and final story takes place around a holiday tree, though it’s not especially seasonal otherwise.
The good: Animated versions of some popular characters from Soviet children’s magazines of the time. Each story has a little moral. The second one ("Gimmebuythatgiftmea") is amusing for parents.
The bad: Engaging for kids, but less so for adults. Quite average.
A Fir Tree Was Born in the Wood (1972) **

The good: It is based on a very well-known winter holiday song, which is well-sung. It more-or-less has the right holiday atmosphere.
The bad: The art direction is not very inspired (a bit like American low-budget TV animation of the period). The song is interrupted before it finishes and the final lines are changed to insert a message about how the tree shouldn’t really be cut down.
Well, Just You Wait (8) (1974) ****

Wolf chases Bunny through a crowd of people celebrating the coming New Year. Along the way, they sing a duet with Bunny as Father Frost (the Russian Santa Claus) and Wolf as his daughter, the Snow Maiden.
The good: A classic, beloved winter holiday cartoon. Lots of action and humour. Plenty of fun scenes, and holiday atmosphere.
The bad: Like always with this series, if you’re looking for depth, you won’t find it. But it’s far less repetitive (due to the many changes of location in each episode) than the Western "Tom & Jerry" that it’s often compared to.
The Fir (1981) ***

The life story of a fir tree, set to classical piano music.
The good: Atmospheric and relaxed, with good music and painted animation.
The bad: Very short (like the other films by Samsonov in this "series"), the ending is quite sudden. A deeper but sadder version of this story is told in The Little Fir (1983).
Wonderful New Year’s Night (1984) ***

Rejected toys from a factory come alive and begin to look for a home.
The good: A surprisingly sweet Estonian winter holiday puppet animation, made more in the style of the 1960s than the 1980s.
The bad: Possibly a bit slow for some? I can’t find anything else bad to say, really, though I don’t think it’s the best film ever, either.
The Blue Arrow (1985) ****

The good: An absolutely charming puppet animation with great holiday spirit, warm feelings and an engaging (and slightly strange) plot.
The bad: This is probably a great simplification of Gianni Rodari’s original novel, so I don’t know what those who are familiar with it will think.
A Lacy Fairy-Tale (1992) ***

The good: Nice folk songs, relaxed, old-timey atmosphere. Slightly odd story in which Father Frost seems to be a young lad who falls in love with a kindred "artist".
The bad: The art, though often nice, is also amateurish in places. The film develops slowly and the plot is rather thin.
Yuletide Stories (1994) ***

Two beautiful, religious Christmas-themed stories. About the night of Christ’s birth, and a good deed that is remembered many decades later
The good: Excellent art direction, music and direction. A very peaceful and introspective atmosphere, like some other Belarusian films around the same time.
The bad: The English translation isn’t as effective as the Russian original, especially for the firt story. Also, I think the atmosphere is stronger than the plots themselves.
The Little Angel (2008) ***

A story about how a Christmas tree toy - a little wax angel - changed everything in the heart of a boy deprived of his mother’s love. Based on a story by Leonid Andreyev, and a poem by Vladimir Nabokov.
The good: Well-drawn, animated with paint-on-glass. Hopeful and wholesome.
The bad: The film does its best to be optimistic, downplay the bad parts of the boy’s character, and assume that the "religious awakening" leads to a happy ending, while the original story is more ambivalent about how much of a difference it can or will ultimately make to the fates of the characters beyond that one Christmas night. Because of that, the story comes across as more honest.
Catboy and the New Year (2016) **

The good: Neat idea: a film based on the drawings & story of a child who misinterprets some of the things adults talk about in amusing ways. A bit like a modern version of the Brumberg sisters' famous Big Troubles (1960), but not as sharp.
The bad: It feels a little artificial. Not all references are understandable unless you live there. It feels like a warmup for the later Pushkin cartoon based on children’s drawings from the same studio: My Pushkin (2023)
Fir Trees (2017) ***

The good: Nice animation (as is often the case from Sharafutdinov). An emotional roller-coaster ride.
The bad: An emotional roller-coaster ride; bizarre sudden tone change from wacky to absolutely depressing.
Umka at the Holiday Tree (2019) **

The good: the "unfinished" story from the 1st two films is finally finished, adapted from the concluding story written by the original author. The art style tries to stay close to the original. There is a bit of the lyricism from the first two films.
The bad: Something about it feels off. It feels quite "modern" and even somewhat hyper. Maybe the stories didn’t need to be finished? It really seemed to me like the open-ended endings of the first two film was a big part of their DNA. Each of them ends with two characters who love each other separated and not knowing if they’ll ever see each other again. On the one hand, I can see the appeal in "finishing" things, but on the other hand…
P.S. My apologies for posting this list so late in the month. I was delayed while I fixed a new bug that had begun to prevent most VK video thumbnails on the site from loading.
































